The debate over the recently passed Arizona Immigration Law has been stirring up emotions in people on both sides of the issue. The new law is the harshest anti-illegal immigration law in the country, and allows police to request identification of citizenship from anyone they have “reasonable suspicion” is an illegal alien. This last attribute of the law is evoking fear in many people who are in fact legal citizens, but are from Hispanic decent. Some people believe that these fears have no legitimacy, and that the law is reasonable and appropriate to the state, but others strongly disagree. The law basically legalizes racial discrimination, and legal Latinos are worried that if they get pulled over by law enforcement they could be detained if they do not have enough identification to prove citizenship with them.
The backers of the new immigration law in Arizona feel that the law is necessary, because Arizona has recently been having serious problems with illegal immigrants. Those in favor of the law have responses to every argument that those who oppose the law can throw at them. In a recent article appearing in Fox News, writer John Lott states some of the main concerns people are having over the law, and how they are not reasonable fears. In reply to the concerns that the allowance of police to retain someone with “reasonable suspicion,” Lott states that cops have to deal with that determination in different aspects of the law everyday. He uses the example of cops not being allowed to “pull over drivers for fear that they are smuggling drugs just because they are black.” He believes people should have faith in police officers to uphold justice in the law, and not use discrimination. Lott also quickly jumps to defend the portion of the law about the identification required of people to prove their citizenship. People fear that driver’s licenses will not be enough and the cops will request more ID. People do not want to have to begin carrying more identification, or to be retained because they forgot it. Lott writes that the law states that “any valid United States federal, state, or local government issued identification” is sufficient. Lott believes that those who oppose the new law are just unreasonably “stirring up the fears of people,” and that the law passed is reasonable for the state of Arizona.
The concerns of those in objection to the law are not without reason though. The fear of racial discrimination and other problems the law may cause legal citizens are completely real. Whether people want to believe it or not, there will always be those in law enforcement that abuse their powers, and unfortunately there will be those that discriminate against minorities as well. You cannot base a law on the precedence that police officers will uphold their honor. The law also allows government officials to arrest people and detain them until their citizenship status is determined. This part of the law restricts the liberty of legal aliens who may be held until their legal citizenship status is proven. Both sides of the issue have reasonable arguments and facts, the controversial law has many parts to it, and some that are more disputed than others, but there can be no doubt the Arizona Immigration Law will be debated for a while yet.
No comments:
Post a Comment