Monday, September 27, 2010

Tourism: What are you really seeing?

Most Americans these days participate in some type of tourism in their lives. Whether a day trip to an amusement park nearby, or a month long backpacking trip halfway around the world, most people at some point in their lives become a “tourist.” The term “tourist” is a loaded term that has evolved in meaning alongside tourism itself. It has developed a derogatory connotation associated with ignorance and stupidity. Tourists are looked down upon as inferior to the smart and cultured “locals.” I think one of the main reasons tourists are so openly laughed at is their impossible dream for having an “authentic” experience. Most tourists travel to a new area and only see the things that a local people want them to see, the “front” view. Chances to see the “back” can be very educational, but sometimes they are also sad and hard to see. When I traveled to  Mexico the last two Februaries I was able to get a glimpse of the “real” Mexico, albeit with the eyes of an outsider. Sometimes seeing the “back” side of tourism really opens your eyes. My trip made me fully appreciate many of the things in my life that we here in the United States take for granted everyday.
I traveled to Mexico with my church in 2009 and 2010. The first year we worked and stayed in a town called Hopelchen. This town is a very small city, completely devoid of “tourists.” There are no hotels in this town because rarely does anyone visit, let alone American tourists. Our group stayed with different host families in the area with one other person from the group. My host parents spoke absolutely no English, so we were completely immersed in the Spanish language and Mexican culture. The experience was amazing. We were really able to see what people in Mexico do and act like on a day-to-day basis, and not in the context of a city frequented by tourists like Cancun, which is almost an American city. While we worked we were visited by many of the local children. It was hard to see so many kids, all dirty with no shoes, being taken care of by older siblings, often only 8 to 10 years of age. They stayed and watched us all day, and during our breaks we would play games with them. Toward the end of our workday more adults from the town would come over to watch and give their thanks. By the end of the week we all felt such a special connection to these people it was very hard to leave. Ill never forget the face of the women who came up to me with tears in her eyes and said “thank you” with a voice full of gratitude. As our vans pulled away the children chased them down the street yelling and waving. I believe this experience was very close to an authentic one, and we defiantly saw the “back” side of the area.
As we drove back to the airport we stayed one night by the pyramids of Chichen Itza, and visited them. It was such a different experience from what we had seen earlier in the week. Tourists taking pictures and stocking up on souvenirs, thinking that they were getting the “authentic” Mexican experience. I overheard one group of tourists telling another how cool haggling with the local merchants was, that they really “felt like they were in the real Mexico.” At the hotel that night we got a chance to talk to our waiter, who peddled souvenirs by the pyramids during the day, and he laughed and called us Gringos.  He really opened up to us telling us all about the silly things he had seen tourists do.
It’s funny to look at the situation from the reverse. Many people look down upon Mexicans, poor ones from rural areas in particular, but when you look at it from their perspective they might look down upon you as well. Seeing the “back” view of an area or culture can give you a new perspective to life and really help you view the world in a different way, and you can take many important lessons away from it. I would encourage all people who travel to try and look deeper into the culture of the area they are visiting and try to really understand it and learn from it. 

Sunday, September 19, 2010

To Believe or Not to Believe: Can We Trust Law Enforcement Officials to Not Discriminate?



            The debate over the recently passed Arizona Immigration Law has been stirring up emotions in people on both sides of the issue. The new law is the harshest anti-illegal immigration law in the country, and allows police to request identification of citizenship from anyone they have “reasonable suspicion” is an illegal alien. This last attribute of the law is evoking fear in many people who are in fact legal citizens, but are from Hispanic decent. Some people believe that these fears have no legitimacy, and that the law is reasonable and appropriate to the state, but others strongly disagree. The law basically legalizes racial discrimination, and legal Latinos are worried that if they get pulled over by law enforcement they could be detained if they do not have enough identification to prove citizenship with them.
            The backers of the new immigration law in Arizona feel that the law is necessary, because Arizona has recently been having serious problems with illegal immigrants. Those in favor of the law have responses to every argument that those who oppose the law can throw at them. In a recent article appearing in Fox News, writer John Lott states some of the main concerns people are having over the law, and how they are not reasonable fears. In reply to the concerns that the allowance of police to retain someone with “reasonable suspicion,” Lott states that cops have to deal with that determination in different aspects of the law everyday. He uses the example of cops not being allowed to “pull over drivers for fear that they are smuggling drugs just because they are black.” He believes people should have faith in police officers to uphold justice in the law, and not use discrimination. Lott also quickly jumps to defend the portion of the law about the identification required of people to prove their citizenship. People fear that driver’s licenses will not be enough and the cops will request more ID. People do not want to have to begin carrying more identification, or to be retained because they forgot it. Lott writes that the law states that “any valid United States federal, state, or local government issued identification” is sufficient. Lott believes that those who oppose the new law are just unreasonably “stirring up the fears of people,” and that the law passed is reasonable for the state of Arizona.
            The concerns of those in objection to the law are not without reason though. The fear of racial discrimination and other problems the law may cause legal citizens are completely real. Whether people want to believe it or not, there will always be those in law enforcement that abuse their powers, and unfortunately there will be those that discriminate against minorities as well. You cannot base a law on the precedence that police officers will uphold their honor. The law also allows government officials to arrest people and detain them until their citizenship status is determined. This part of the law restricts the liberty of legal aliens who may be held until their legal citizenship status is proven. Both sides of the issue have reasonable arguments and facts, the controversial law has many parts to it, and some that are more disputed than others, but there can be no doubt the Arizona Immigration Law will be debated for a while yet.

            

Monday, September 13, 2010

Home: You Don't Know What You Got Till It's Gone


Merriam-Webster’s dictionary defines displacement as being “removed from the usual or proper place,” but in the context of displaced persons it means so much more. The film The Long Way Home is about the journey Jews, and other “displaced persons,” went through after the Holocaust. Home means something different to all of us, but most people can associate a certain place or area with the term home, somewhere they are familiar with and feel the most comfortable. Being displaced means that you have nowhere to live and no home to associate as your own. It can be very disconcerting to not have anywhere to live, or to not know where home is. Many people who lost homes and family members during the war were forced to face this problem with no obvious solution seen in the future. After the traumatic events that the Holocaust subjected them to, not having any home to go back to made already miserable lives almost unbearable.
To be displaced is to be without a place to call home. Being provided with housing accommodations of some sort does not make that place a home, especially if the accommodations are extremely poor, like in the case of the Displaced Persons camps across Europe after World War II. The setting of these camps were dismal and not much better than what the living situation in the Nazi concentration camps were like, many people concentrated into small, unpleasant, areas. The only hope that these people had was the idea of a new independent Jewish state in Palestine. Many other peoples have been forced out of their homes, whether due to natural disasters, people, or any other reason, in human history.  In addition to post-holocaust movement, another well-known example of people being forced out of their home, and becoming “displaced persons,” was the Native Americans in Georgia who were forced from their homes and sent west on the famous “trail of tears.” Although these events took place far apart in history and time, all of the people involved went through a similar situation. They were all involuntarily removed from their homes and forced to move to a new and unfamiliar location. The loss of that place called home causes emotional stress that has lasting impacts on those individuals involved.
The word “home” to me has many levels of meaning. Home is the house where I was raised in the town I lived in my whole life, but it is more than just a location. Home is where my family is. Without my parents and siblings living in my house it would not feel like home. It would be familiar to me, but it would not have the emotional connection that comes with the loaded term “home.” There are many places where I can feel “at home,” but there is nothing quite like my actual house. I have always had a rather wandering heart, and am able to feel comfortable and “at home” in new locations once I am used to them, but there is still always that sense of relief when I get back to my house. Whenever I travel I always adjust quickly and my “old” home seems so far and foreign to me, but the second that I walk in the door at my house a wave of familiarity washes over me, “NOW I’m home.” Until that moment I forget how much home means to me, but as soon as Im reminded I cant understand how I could have forgotten. The idea of being forced from my home, and no longer having that association is a scary thought. I can’t even begin to imagine how “displaced persons” must feel.

Sunday, September 5, 2010

Our Great Responsibility


            Whether you feel it personally or not, colonialism has affected the lives of most people in the world, and everyone in the United States. The United States came about through colonialism, and if it wasn’t colonized, those of us that consider it home would not be here. Most people however feel the effects of colonialism on a more personal level. Colonialism has impacted my life in many ways, some more significant than others. I live where I do, in the world that I am familiar with, because of colonialism, but it also effects me in a deeper way. I hear about and see terrible things that my country has done, and is doing, all around the world and I feel a responsibility. I feel a responsibility to take action and to help those nations and people that have been hurt by American colonialism.
            American Colonialism has hurt individual people and large groups of people as well. A long time before I was born colonialism killed and enslaved many native peoples to the Americas. European countries sent their people to America to colonize it. In the process we, (we being white people with European ancestries) were forced to push out, and many times just kill, the local inhabitants of the land. Some entire groups of people were killed off, and many others just severely decimated. The Aztecs and Mayans in Central and South America were some of the first peoples to be effected by this European colonization, but Native Americas in what is now the United States were also kicked out of their homes. These people were forced to leave lands that their tribes and ancestors had inhabited for as far back as their knowledge went. I believe that as an American citizen, even though those of us alive today obviously had no personal role in early colonialism, we bear the responsibility of helping those that were hurt by our ancestors.
            That’s not to say that we today have no personal impact on modern colonialism though, as consumerist Americans we contribute to, if not physical colonialism, then economical colonialism. Companies from the United States, like McDonalds and Burger King, set up their businesses in foreign nations and detract from local foods and local restaurant businesses. Other companies, like Nike and GAP, have sweatshops in other countries. When you buy shoes from Nike or a sweater from GAP you are contributing to the encouragement of using foreign, and often child, labor. As consumers I believe that it is important for people to stop and think before they purchase things from certain companies. If people stood together and didn’t buy items from companies that used foreign or child labor than those businesses would be forced to change their ways in order to get their clients back. I believe we have a responsibility as buyers to consider the consequences those different items we take for granted have on other places and people.
            I also personally feel a responsibility to do more.  I believe that we owe other nations more than just not contributing to modern colonialism, I think we owe them for the past imperialism problems our country has subjected them too.  Humanitarian trips and organizations are becoming more and more popular in modern society, people are beginning to see that its necessary to help others less fortunate than ourselves, but we can do more. As fortunate people whose lives may have personally benefited from colonialism, we have a moral obligation to give back to those that were not so lucky, and ended up on the wrong end of the stick.
            However colonialism has effected your life, whether directly or indirectly, I bet most people, if they think hard enough, can think of some way it has personally impacted their life. Some people may have friends or relatives that were individually hurt by colonialism, and others, like myself, may just feel a responsibly to try and right the atrocities of our ancestors. The problem most people have when thinking about colonialism is that they assume colonialism is just the physical take over of a country and happened mostly in the past. The truth of the matter is that colonialism is as much present in modern society as it used to be; it has just taken on a new form.