I do not believe that borders are necessary. While borders can exist in ones mind, having a definitive, physical, border tends to only cause dispute. Having borders in your own mind, or in the mind of a population as a group can help to create a unique culture and build a stronger sense of togetherness, but physical lines do not need to be drawn.
A border cannot contain people, languages, or cultures, so what is the purpose of these boundaries? Borders are more of a guideline. They define the end of one area, and the start of somewhere new, but who controls these borders? What is the real difference from one side to the other? Do the people surrounding these perimeters have a say? Borders are controlled by governments or leaders, and are often fought over. Many people have died fighting in wars over disputed lands, and for what? Nations go to war over areas of disputed resources, but they often fight over areas that benefit no one. Even the lands with valuable resources, are they improving the lives of the families who lost loved ones in the fight? Is anyone really benefiting?
Another problem with borders is the differentiation between people. People are inherently different from one another, and we instinctively categorize each other into different groups, but do we really need another way to do that? People differentiate between each other through ethnicity, beliefs, size, class, and many other ways. Borders distinguish between people in a geographical way, but it doesn’t really make them any different than someone else other than current location. Borders just enforce the open acknowledgment that people should set themselves apart from others, that they are different. That’s just one step closer to people judging themselves as better than others, and discriminating against others that they believe “inferior.”
People are distinct enough through languages and customs, and they will be that way regardless of what some higher power says is the border of their lands. Often times, after a territory dispute, people who were once a part of one nation are now a part of another. Has their culture, and language, and beliefs now changed? No, they are still psychologically as much a part of their old nation as the people still remaining in it. So what is that border really doing? I believe that borders exist solely for those in control, for those who feel the need to have everything defined.
I believe that having borders can directly cause problems, but I believe the problems they cause indirectly can often be more severe. Discrimination has been, and continues to be, a huge problem in our world today. People need to overcome their desire to see the differences in people, or at least the need for those differences to be important, and begin to see all the similarities that we as humans share. If people embraced their likeness the world would be a much simpler and kinder place. I believe that borders only reinforce those differences that people see in one another, so I believe that we do not need borders and should not have them.
In the second and fourth paragraphs you pose lots of questions. Be sure you never ask a questions that you don't answer in the same essay.
ReplyDelete"Nations go to war over areas of disputed resources, but they often fight over areas that benefit no one." Examples?
"...we instinctively categorize each other into different groups." Why do you suppose that is?
"Often times, after a territory dispute, people who were once a part of one nation are now a part of another." Again, you need examples here to support your claim.